ManiMani Ideation
Reference Catalog
← All Concepts

DP3.1 Catalog Upsert Smoke

brega Wip

Setup

IP: brega

Genres: friend_slop, simulation

Goals: laugh_at_chaos, feel_expressive_and_seen

Designer: dp31_tester

Progress

Current phase: 2 / 6

Continue →

Gate Decision History

Phase Verdict Attempt Violations Timestamp Details
Phase 1 PASS 1 No violations (PASS) 2026-05-05 02:39:58.685909+00:00 View
Phase 2 ITERATE 1
ZZTest Catalog Game 1777948798: The game name is a placeholder and provides no information to evaluate Gen-Z Drifter Appeal.
ZZTest Catalog Game 1777948798: The game name is a placeholder and provides no information to evaluate IP Alignment.
ZZTest Catalog Game 1777948798: The game name is a placeholder, making it impossible to confirm it doesn't belong to an excluded genre.
trinity: The primary game is a placeholder, preventing a complete evaluation of the trinity's fit with the Brega IP.
trinity: The primary game is a placeholder, preventing a complete evaluation of the trinity's appeal to the Web Gen-Z Drifter persona.
trinity: The primary game is a placeholder, preventing a complete evaluation of the trinity's collective support for the experience goals.
2026-05-05 02:40:14.076911+00:00 View
Phase 2 ITERATE 2
Melvoir: The description of Melvoir as an 'idle' game that 'simulates an RPG without any combat visuals' suggests a lack of immediate visual spectacle and engagement, making it difficult for a bored teenager to grasp and engage within 3 seconds.
Melvoir: Melvoir's 'Idle' genre and description as an 'RPG without any combat visuals' does not align with Brega's design pillars of 'chaotic/expressive casual' gameplay.
trinity: The inclusion of Melvoir, an idle game focused on passive progression without combat visuals, creates a significant dissonance with Brega's core IP pillars of 'chaotic/expressive casual' gameplay, making the overall trinity incoherent.
trinity: Melvoir's nature as an idle, system-driven game that 'simulates an RPG without any combat visuals' directly contradicts the Web Gen-Z Drifter persona's need for fast, reactive, expressive gameplay with zero reading or tutorials.
2026-05-19 23:29:37.411911+00:00 View